TSN comeback players of the year

The Sporting News names Cliff Lee and Fernando Tatis Comeback Players of the Year.

I've always felt that this award should go to players battling back from adversity rather than bouncing back from a subpar season. Tatis, who's been away from baseball for years, would qualify for a comeback award in my mind. Lee is more of a "bounce-back" player of the year. Joe Crede would've been a good "comeback" candidate had he not gotten injured again.

TSN managers of the year

Notorious in elections, Florida is grade-A when it comes to baseball managers. The Sporting News leaves no hanging chads in selection Joe Maddon (Rays) and Fredi Gonzalez (Marlins) as MLB skippers of the year.

I like the Maddon selection, but Lou Piniella, Joe Torre and Tony La Russa are more deserving than Gonzalez in the National League. I like Fredi, and I think he did a great job with Florida this year, but consider what these other three managers accomplished:

Piniella: best record in the N.L., back-to-back N.L. Central division titles
Torre: first place in N.L. West, lifting the Dodgers over Arizona late in the year
La Russa: With a decimated pitching staff, kept Cardinals in race until September