Showing posts with label closers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label closers. Show all posts

Thursday, June 9, 2011

2011 MLB Closers

***MLB closer report updated 6/9/11 @ 12:28 AM CST***

Latest news:

***6/8/11***Casey Janssen (2.08 ERA, 1.04 WHIP, 1 S) becomes the sixth Blue Jays pitcher to earn a save chance in 2011 and converts his first of the season in a wild, 9-8 victory over the Royals. Janssen wasn't so smooth on the way to his eighth career save giving up a run on a pair of hits, but he got it done. Add his name to the mix at the back of the Blue Jays bullpen. It would appear any one of five different relievers could get saves chances moving forward.

***6/8/11***Craig Kimbrel (3.19 ERA, 1.29 WHIP, 18 S) blows his fifth save in an eventual 3-2 Braves loss to the Marlins in 10 innings. Kimbrel gave up two runs on a walk and two hits in the ninth, but he did strike out the side while throwing 28 pitches. Jonny Venters fans will say Venters deserves to be the Braves close with his stellar numbers, but the reality of the situation is Kimbrel is near the league lead in saves and pitching well on most nights. The Braves will continue to trot him out there as long as he's performing well most nights. That said, Venters, a lefty could easily earn the job if Kimbrel falers. With Eric O'Flaherty, another lefty, available to set up in his place, Atlanta is covered if a change is ever needed.

***6/8/11***Sergio Santos (2.10 ERA, 1.07 WHIP, 11 S) drops his second loss as he allows the Mariners to get past the White Sox, 7-4 in 10 innings. Santos worked the top of the 10th in a tie game and surrendered the three runs on three hits and a pair of walks. It was just Santos' second bad outing of the season, but both have been real clunkers. Much of the time he looks like a No. 1 closer, but then there are nights like tonight. Consider Santos a high-end No. 2 option with potential for great upside.

***6/8/11***Matt Capps (4.50 ERA, 0.93 WHIP, 8 S) suffers his third blown save in his last four chances as he coughs up the lead in an eventual 3-2 Twins victory over the Indians in 10 innings. Capps entered the ninth with a one-run lead, and after retiring the first two batters, he offers up a home run to Jack Hannahan. Capps did earn the win after Chris Perez gave the lead right back in the bottom of the inning. Phil Dumatrait earns the save for the Twins, but he owns just one hold in nine innings. That means he's highly unlikely to make a run at Capps job. Joe Nathan is Capps' biggest threat, and Nathan remains on the DL. Consider Capps a low-end option for saves in fantasy play. He's not pitching terribly badly, but he's gone just eight for 13 in save chances on a bad team.

***6/8/11***Chris Perez (2.70 ERA, 1.33 WHIP, 15 S) stumbles to his second loss of the year in a 3-2 Indians faltering at the hand of the Twins in 10. Perez gave up a double and RBI single in the ninth inning. Most troubling, however, continues to be his lack of dominance in terms of strikeouts. With no strikeouts today, his K/9 is weak: 5.0, and his K/BB rate is just 1.1. He's still incredibly difficult to hit (.226 BAA and .268 BABIP), but those numbers are elevated over his career averages a touch. Over the course of the season things should even out for Perez who is still 15 for 16 is saves chances, but right now he's no better than a higher-end No. 2 closer.

***6/8/11***J.J. Putz (2.00 ERA, 0.89 WHIP, 17 S) surrenders his second blown save in three chances in the 10th inning as the Diamondbacks eventually lose to the Pirates, 3-2 in 12 innings. Putz entered with a one-run lead but gave up two hits, including an RBI single to Neil Walker to blow the lead. Putz did strike out two Pirates and remains a high-end No. 1 option as a closer.

***6/8/11***Brandon League (4.50 ERA, 1.08 WHIP, 17 S) saves his eighth straight game in a 7-4 Mariners win at the White Sox in 10 innings. League hasn't allowed an earned run since way back on May 13th, and his ugly start to the season is almost forgotten. He's working his way up the ranks as a legitimate No. 2 closer right now, thanks in great part to the Mariners' winning ways.

***6/8/11***Ryan Madson (2.00 ERA, 1.11 WHIP, 14 S) is still perfect in saves chances - now 14 for 14 - in a 2-0 Phillies win over the Dodgers. Madson worked a shutout ninth after a run on two hits the last time out. The long-time setup man appears poised to emerge as a No. 1 closer, but he's not quite there yet. Three messy innings in his last eight leave a little to be desired, even if he's perfect in saves chances.

***6/8/11***Kyle Farnsworth (1.17 ERA, 0.70 WHIP, 13 S) finishes off his eighth straight save in a 4-3 Rays win over the Angels in 10 innings. Farnsworth continues to roll like never before in the closer role. He'll fall back to earth eventually, so peg him as a No. 2 closer for the time being.

***6/8/11***Kevin Gregg (2.96 ERA, 1.56 WHIP, 12 S) posts his fifth straight save in a 3-2 Orioles win over the Athletics. Gregg has looked good over this recent stretch, but his WHIP is still sky-high. He can only be trusted as a low-end option for saves, or as a emergency No. 2 if needed.

***6/8/11***Carlos Marmol (3.21 ERA, 1.25 WHIP, 11 S) bounces back from a pair of blown saves with his first save since May 29th in a 4-1 Cubs win at the Reds. Marmol did not record a strikeout, but he does go 1-2-3 in the ninth for the first time since May 12th. Marmol tends to have plenty of up-and-down moments, but he's good enough to be trusted as an above-average No. 2 closer.

***6/8/11***Mark Melancon (1.78 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 6 S) puts together his fifth straight save in a 4-1 Astros victory over the Cardinals. Melancon worked a one-hit, shutout ninth for his sixth save. There's news that regular closer Brandon Lyon will be brought along slowly once he returns from a rehab assignment. That means Melancon can still offer fantasy owners value into next week with regard to saves.

***6/8/11***The White Sox recall Lucas Harrell (9.00 ERA, 2.50 WHIP, 0 S) to fill the injured Jake Peavy's roster spot. Harrell will work out of the bullpen in long relief.

***6/8/11***The Yankees place Joba Chamberlain (2.83 ERA, 1.05 WHIP, 0 S) on the 15-day DL retroactive to June 6th. Chamberlain is suffering from a right elbow flexor strain. He had been one of the better fantasy options in terms of setup men. The Yankees will likely turn to a committee approach with both Chamberlain and Rafael Soriano (5.40 ERA, 1.73 WHIP, 1 S) out.

***6/8/11***Alfredo Aceves (3.29 ERA, 1.24 WHIP, 1 S) earns his third career save in an 11-6 Red Sox blowout of the Yankees. Aceves worked 3 2/3 innings for the save and gave up one run. He's done a nice job in multiple roles for the Red Sox, but closing games will not be asked of him.

----------
Current list of MLB closers and candidates for the 2011 season. Closers are listed at the top under each team name. Their competition follows. This list will be updated throughout the regular season:

Arizona Diamondbacks:
J.J. Putz
David Hernandez
Esmerling Vasquez
Juan Gutierrez - 15-day DL as of May 24, 2011 (Right shoulder inflammation)
Sam Demel - 15-day DL as of May 22, 2011 (Right shoulder tendinitis)
Aaron Heilman
Joe Paterson (L)
Zach Kroenke (L)
Kam Mickolio
***6/4/11***J.J. Putz (1.80 ERA, 0.84 WHIP, 17 S) bounces back from his first blown save to file away No. 17 in a 2-0 Diamondbacks win over the Nationals. Putz continues to put together an all-star-type first half to his season. The last time he made the Midsummer Classic was 2007. Putz is looking like a sure-fire No. 1 closer and can be considered one of the game's elite once again.

Atlanta Braves:
Craig Kimbrell
Jonny Venters (L)
Scott Linebrink
George Sherrill (L)
Eric O'Flaherty (L)
Christhian Martinez
Scott Proctor
Cory Gearrin
Peter Moylan - 15-day DL as of Apr 15, 2011 (Lower back strain)
Kris Medlen - 15-day DL as of Mar 27, 2011 (Recovery from right elbow surgery)
***6/7/11***Craig Kimbrel (2.70 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, 18 S) cruises to his seventh straight save in a 1-0 Braves victory over the Marlins. Kimbrel looked dominant. He fanned the first batter he faced and allowed just a two-out walk before getting Chris Coghlan to loop a liner to short to end the game. Kimbrel hasn't allowed a run now in five straight outings. He's worked seven straight saves without blowing a single game. Kimbrel can be considered a low-end No. 1 closer at this time, although that save total of 18 is second-best in baseball. Kimbrel doesn't have much room for error with Jonny Venters and arguably the best bullpen in baseball backing him up.

Baltimore Orioles:
Kevin Gregg
Koji Uehara
Michael Gonzalez (L)
Jim Johnson
Jeremy Accardo
Alfredo Simon
Clay Rapada (L)
Chris Jakubauskas
Kevin Gregg (3.09 ERA, 1.69 WHIP, 11 S) completes his fourth straight save in a 4-2 Orioles win over the Athletics. Gregg worked a t ninth with two strikeouts, throwing nine of is 14 pitches for strikes. He hasn't allowed a run since May 20th and still sports an ugly 1.69 WHIP. That's all you need to know. Gregg may be on a run of good luck, but bad luck is always lurking with this low-end saves option.

Boston Red Sox:
Jonathan Papelbon
Daniel Bard
Dan Wheeler
Bobby Jenks
Franklin Morales (L) - 15-day DL as of May 26, 2011 (Strained left forearm)
Matt Albers
Rich Hill (L) - 15-day DL as of Jun 2, 2011 (Sprained left elbow)
Scott Atchison
Tommy Hottovy (L)
Alfredo Aceves
Dennys Reyes (L) - restricted list
***6/7/11***Jonathan Papelbon (4.50 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, 12 S) converts his seventh straight save in a 6-4 Red Sox win at the Yankees. Once again, Papelbon coughs up a run - the fifth time that's happened in his last seven outings. This time he walks the leadoff man and yields an eventual RBI single to the light-hitting Jorge Posada. Don't criticize Papelbon, too much, though. Posada produced three hits on the night, and Papelbon struck out two Yankees in the frame. While some have Papelbon on watch with the young and talented Daniel Bard producing stellar numbers (and throwing a shutout eighth), consider that Papelbon also reached a milestone on this night: his 200th save. Papelbon is the fastest ever to that mark, which means his track record is second to none in terms of volume of saves. That alone means his job is safe, even with the recent struggles. Papelbon also appealed his three-game suspension for this past weekend's ejection which leaves his status as active until the process concludes. Continue to view Papelbon as a No. 1 closer.

Chicago Cubs:
Carlos Marmol
Kerry Wood
Sean Marshall (L)
John Grabow (L)
Jeff Samardzija
James Russell (L)
Brian Schlitter - 60-day DL as of Mar 22, 2011 (Strained right flexor pronator)
***6/5/11***Carlos Marmol (3.33 ERA, 1.30 WHIP, 10 SV) surrenders to the Cardinals in the ninth for his fourth blown save in a 3-2 Cubs loss in 10 innings. Marmol struck out a pair of Cardinals but allowed Ryan Theriot to double in the tying run before getting the final out of the inning. It's Marmol's second blown save in five days. He sees his ERA jump from 1.17 a week ago to the low-to-mid threes. Marmol is looking like a No. 2 closer at this time due to his inconsistency and the poor starting pitching the Cubs are routinely throwing in front of an otherwise setup group.

Chicago White Sox:
Sergio Santos
Matt Thornton (L)
Jesse Crain
Chris Sale (L)
Will Ohman (L)
Tony Pena - 15-day DL as of May 28, 2011 (Right elbow tendinitis)
Brian Bruney
Lucas Harrell
***6/6/11***Sergio Santos (1.24 ERA, 0.93 WHIP, 11 S) makes good on his 5th straight save in a 3-1 White Sox victory over the Mariners. Santos went 1-2-3 in the ninth with a strikeout giving him 6 1/3 no-hit innings since blowing his only save of the year on May 20th. Santos also yielded his only runs in that outing. His only blemish is a rather high walk rate (4.5 BB/P entering Monday). It's not much a problem, however, as he's well over a strikeout per inning and has limited opponents to a mere 13 hits in 29 innings. Santos' stuff looks outstanding, and despite his minimal track record he's emerging as a must-own fantasy closer. Elite level? Perhaps.

Cincinnati Reds:
Francisco Cordero
Nick Masset
Bill Bray (L)
Logan Ondrusek
Jose Arredondo
Sam LeCure - 15-day DL as of May 23, 2011 (Strained right forearm)
Jeremy Horst (L)
Carlos Fisher
Aroldis Chapman (L) - 15-day DL as of May 16, 2011 (Left shoulder inflammation)
Jared Burton - 60-day DL as of Mar 29, 2011 (Right shoulder inflammation)
***6/3/11***Francisco Cordero (1.65 ERA, 0.88 WHIP, 11 S) makes it back-to-back converted saves in a 2-1 Reds win over the Dodgers. Cordero is a bit of an enigma at this time with his sparkling numbers and yet just 11 saves. He doesn't strike batters out like he used to (6.6 K/9 in 2011), and his three-year numbers suggest he won't return to the double-digit K/9 he had produced for his career previously. The Reds stand just two games over .500 at this time, meaning he's been partially limited by his teams play in terms of chances. Cordero should be regarded as a high-end No. 2 closer at this time. He can rack up big saves numbers if the Reds go on a run.

Cleveland Indians:
Chris Perez
Rafael Perez (L)
Tony Sipp (L)
Joe Smith
Chad Durbin
Vinnie Pestano
Frank Herrmann
***6/7/11******6/7/11***Chris Perez (2.42 ERA, 1.30 WHIP, 15 S) nabs his 10th straight save in a 1-0 Indians win over the Twins. Perez punched out Michael Cuddyer to end the game with a strikeout. His strikeout rate (5.24 K/9) is concerning, especially considering Perez's walk rate is almost identical (4.84 K/9). He is, however, getting the job done with 15 saves in 16 chances. If Perez can improve on those numbers he has a shot to become a No. 1 closer in fantasy play. Until then, he's hovering as a mid- to high-end No. 2.

Colorado Rockies:
Huston Street
Matt Belisle
Rafael Betancourt
Matt Lindstrom
Matt Reynolds (L)
Rex Brothers (L)
Matt Daley - 15-day DL as of Jun 1, 2011 (Right shoulder inflammation)
***6/6/11***Huston Street (3.54 ERA, 1.11 WHIP, 16 S) produces back-to-back saves for the first time since May 20th in a 3-0 Rockies shutout of the Padres. Street fans two batters and goes 1-2-3 in the ninth, and that gives him 2 1/3 innings of spotless frames over his last three outings. Street is now strikeout out 8.4 batters per nine innings. He manages to find a bumpy road here and there, but overall he's a solid play as a No. 1 closer.

Detroit Tigers:
Jose Valverde
Joaquin Benoit
Brad Thomas (L) - 15-day DL as of May 11, 2011 (Left elbow inflammation)
Daniel Schlereth (L)
Al Alburquerque
Charlie Furbush (L)
Enrique Gonzalez
David Purcey (L)
Adam Wilk (L)
Joel Zumaya - 60-day DL as of Mar 30, 2011 (Right elbow inflammation)
***6/1/11***Jose Valverde handles save No. 14 in a 4-2 Tigers triumph over the Twins. Valverde, who recently worked three saves in two days thanks to a weekend double header, was less than brilliant. He walked two Twins including an intentional pass to Justin Morneau, but he got out of the inning unscathed. In fairness, Valverde is pitching more like a No. 2 closer right now, but he's got the saves total and the overpowering stuff that fantasy owners love to see.

Florida Marlins:
Leo Nunez
Brian Sanches
Mike Dunn (L)
Clay Hensley - 15-day DL as of Jun 2, 2011 (Sprained right shoulder)
Randy Choate (L)
Burke Badenhop
Ryan Webb
Edward Mujica
***6/3/11***Leo Nunez (3.54 ERA, 1.21 WHIP, 19 S) scuffles to his second blown save and second loss of the season in a 6-5 Marlins loss to the Brewers. Nunez served up a two-run homer to pinch hitter Ryan Braun in the ninth inning, which could happen to any closer. Nunez entered the game with a 3:1 K/BB ratio and a MLB-leading 19 saves. He has enjoyed one of the better stretches of his seven-year career over the first two months of 2011. His job is very much safe despite the second blown save, but his status as an elite or even No. 1 closer should be in question moving forward. Nunez' numbers suggest he'll fall back to the pack over the remainder of the season and serve more as a high-end No. 2 closer.

Houston Astros:
Brandon Lyon - 15-day DL as of May 5, 2011 (Right biceps tendinitis & rotator tear)
Mark Melancon
Jeff Fulchino
Enerio Del Rosario
Wilton Lopez
Jose Valdez
Sergio Escalona (L)
Fernando Rodriguez
Alberto Arias - 15-day DL as of Mar 22, 2011 (Recovery from right shoulder surgery)
***6/7/11***Brandon Lyon (7.15 ERA, 2.12 WHIP, 4 S) continues to progress in his attempt to return from a biceps issue and partial rotator cuff tear. A perfect inning at Triple-A in his first rehab stint is a step in the right direction. There's no guarantee he returns to the closer role in Houston with Mark Melancon outpitching Lyon's early-season work, but he'll at least stand next in line for a guy that's never been a bullpen stopper in the past.

Kansas City Royals:
Joakim Soria
Aaron Crow
Tim Collins (L)
Blake Wood
Louis Coleman
Everett Teaford (L)
Greg Holland
Henry Barrera - 60-day DL as of Mar 13, 2011 (Right elbow sprain)
***6/6/11***Joakim Soria (5.33 ERA, 1.37 WHIP, 7 S) picks up his 4th win in a 3-2, 11-inning Royals win over the Blue Jays. Soria threw a stress-free 10th and 11th inning giving him five straight innings of no-hit baseball. Soria owns just a single strikeout over those frames, but it's a positive trend compared the the previous three blown saves he stumbled thru from May 24th thru 30th. Soria is more than capable to bounce back from his setbacks, but while he's pitching for a sub-.500 Royals team with lackluster numbers Soria is climbing back from low-end closer status. Aaron Crow managers will be upset to learn that Soria has reclaimed the team's closer job while Crow never even sniffed a save chance. Crow has the superior numbers this year, but track record falls heavily to the Soria side of this closer battle.

Los Angeles Angels:
Jordan Walden
Fernando Rodney
Scott Downs (L)
Hisanori Takahashi (L)
Trevor Bell
Rich Thompson
Kevin Jepsen
Francisco Rodriguez - 15-day DL as of May 10, 2011 (Sore right shoulder)
***6/4/11***Javy Guerra (3.24 ERA, 1.32 WHIP, 1 S) earns his first MLB win in a 4-1 Dodgers triumph over the Reds in 11 innings. Guerra is in the mix for saves in a battered Dodgers bullpen, but he's perhaps too erratic to get many chances (5.4 BB/9 in AA). Vicente Padilla is expected back off the DL soon and will likely take over the interim closer role for the Dodgers while Jonathan Broxton is on the shelf.

Los Angeles Dodgers:
Jonathon Broxton - 15-day DL as of May 4, 2011 (Bone spur, right elbow)
Hong Chih Kuo (L) - 15-day DL as of May 10, 2011 (Anxiety disorder)
Vincente Padilla - 15-day DL as of May 14, 2011 (Right forearm discomfort)
Javy Guerra
Matt Guerrier
Mike MacDougal
Kenley Jansen - 15-day DL as of May 29, 2011 (Right shoulder inflammation)
Blake Hawksworth
Scott Elbert (L)
Ramon Troncoso
Josh Lindblom
***5/20/11***Mike MacDougal faces just one batter to record his first save of 2011, a 6-4 Dodgers extra-inning win over the White Sox. With the Dodger bullpen in flux due to the absence of injured closer Jonathan Broxton and setup man Vicente Padilla, McDougal is a fringe option for saves moving forward. Matt Guerrier actually started the inning for the Dodgers but couldn't get through. Fireballer Kenley Jansen provides a third option until Padilla returns, which should be back on May 29th. Any fantasy waiver-wire Dodgers bullpen pickup should last you just over a week until Padilla returns, unless someone gets hot enough to hold the spot.

Milwaukee Brewers:
John Axford
Kameron Loe
LaTroy Hawkins
Zach Braddock (L)
Mitch Stetter (L) - 15-day DL as of May 15, 2011 (Labral irritation, left hip)
Marco Estrada
Sergio Mitre
Tim Dillard
Brandon Kintzler - 15-day DL as of May 5, 2011 (Strained right triceps)
Takashi Saito - 15-day DL as of Apr 6, 2011 (Strained left hamstring)
Mitch Stetter - 15-day DL as of May 15, 2011 (Labral irritation, left hip)
***6/5/11***John Axford (3.29 ERA, 1.54 WHIP, 16 S) earns his 13th straight save in a 6-5 Brewers win at the Marlins in 11 innings. Nothing seems to change with Axford who gives up a walk and a hit and still manages to work through the jam for the save. He threw just nine of his 17 pitches for strikes. To his credit, Axford often gets the job done, but it's rarely pretty. Despite being among the league leaders in saves with 16, Axford is a candidate for a severe meltdown due to his wildness. His stuff looks great, but he looks like a No. 2 closer in fantasy play. Axford may get Monday off after working in three straight games.

Minnesota Twins:
Matt Capps
Joe Nathan - 15-day DL as of May 24, 2011 (Right flexor muscle strain)
Glen Perkins (L) - 15-Day DL a as of May 22, 2011 (Right oblique strain)
Kevin Slowey - 15-day DL as of May 21, 2011 (Abdominal strain)
Phil Dumatrait (L)
Alex Burnett
Jose Mijares (L)
Jim Hoey
Chuck James (L)
***6/6/11***Matt Capps (4.33 ERA, 0.89 WHIP, 8 S) earns his first save in almost three weeks as he pitches the Twins past the Indians, 6-4. Capps walked the leadoff man but battled back with a strikeout and double-play ground out. He blew his last two save chances back on May 21st and 23rd, but Capps hasn't allowed a run in 4 outings since then. He's been erratic is the closer role in the past, and with the Twins struggling to string wins together, Capps is more of a low-end option at this time.

New York Mets:
Francisco Rodriguez
Jason Isringhausen
Taylor Buchholz - 15-day DL as of May 30, 2011 (Right shoulder fatigue)
Tim Byrdak (L)
Mike O'Connor (L)
Pedro Beato
Bobby Parnell
Manny Acosta
***6/7/11***Fernando Rodriguez (3.03 ERA, 1.52 WHIP, 17 S) makes it 16 straight saves in a 2-1 Mets win at the Brewers. K-Rod finally flashes some dominance going 1-2-3 in the ninth with a pair of strike outs, but he topped out at just 90 MPH on the gun with his four-seam fastball. Instead, he used breaking pitches and changeups to get the job done. Rodriguez had given up eight earned runs over his last 4 1/3 innings on 11 hits, so this is at least a step in the right direction. Despite his 17 saves, K-Rod is looking more like a No. 2 option for closing games at this time. That he's recorded 16 saves since his last blown save is remarkable considering a shaky 1.52 WHIP and recent performance.

New York Yankees:
Mariano Rivera
Rafael Soriano - 15-day DL as of May 14, 2011 (Sore right elbow)
Joba Chamberlain - 15-day DL as of June 6, 2011 (Right elbow flexor strain)
David Robertson
Boone Logan (L)
Hector Noesi
Luis Ayala
Lance Pendleton
Jeff Marquez
Pedro Feliciano (L) - 60-day DL as of Mar 22, 2011 (Strained left rotator cuff)
Damaso Marte (L) - 60-day DL as of Mar 30, 2011 (Left shoulder & labrum inflammation)
***6/5/11***Marino Rivera (1.90 ERA, 1.06 WHIP, 16 S) produces his third straight save in a 5-3 Yankees win over the Angels. Rivera pitched himself into a jam this time out, allowing a pair of singles with one out before getting Torii Hunter to bounce into a game-ending double play. Baseball's active all-time saves leader finishes off No. 575, leaving him 26 away from the record Trevor Hoffman set last season. Rivera remains the elite option in fantasy play at closer.

Oakland Athletics:
Andrew Bailey
Brian Fuentes (L)
Grant Balfour
Brad Ziegler
Michael Wuertz
Joey Devine
Craig Breslow (L)
Bobby Cramer (L)
***6/4/11***Andrew Bailey (3.00 ERA, 1.00 WHIP, 0 S) blows his first save opportunity of the year in the 11th of an eventual 9-8 Athletics loss to the Red Sox in 14 innings. Bailey struck out two, gave up back to back doubles, intentionally walked Dustin Pedroia and then struck out Drew Sutton to finish his frame. Bailey touched 95 MPH on the radar gun a few times with his four-seam fastball. He's still the A's closer despite the shaky outing, and Bailey is good enough to re-emerge as a No. 1 closer in fantasy play.

Philadelphia Phillies:
Brad Lidge - 60-day DL as of Mar 25, 2011 (Strained rotator cuff)
-or- Ryan Madson
Jose Contreras
Danys Baez
Antonio Bastardo (L)
Kyle Kendrick
J.C. Romero (L)
Michael Stutes
David Herndon
***6/6/11***Ryan Madson (2.08 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 13 S) makes it a perfect 13 for 13 in saves chances in a 3-1 Phillies win over the Dodgers. It wasn't a clean performance. Madson gave up double, single and RBI ground out before punching out the last two batters he faced. Madson has only allowed runs in four of his 26 innings, but he's given up five earned over his last seven. He's all but taken over Brad Lidge's closer job, and Lidge is now suffering from elbow pain while rehabbing his shoulder. Madson ranks as a high-end No. 2 closer due to his limited experience as a closer on a good team.

Pittsburgh Pirates:
Joel Hanrahan
Jose Veras
Evan Meek
Joe Beimel (L)
Chris Resop
Daniel McCutchen
Tony Watson (L)
Mike Crotta - 15-day DL as of May 11, 2011 (Right elbow inflammation)
Kevin Hart - 60-day DL as of Mar 18, 2011 (Right shoulder soreness)
***6/7/11***Joel Hanrahan (1.63 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, 15 S) is 15 for 15 in saves chances as he closes out an 8-5 Pirates win over the Diamondbacks. Hanrahan struck out Kelly Johnson and Justin Upton in the ninth inning, giving him 25 K in 27 2/3 innings. He's limiting hits and walks and working his way up the closer rankings steadily as a potential No. 1 option, though is track record suggests he's a notch lesser than that tier.

St. Louis Cardinals:
Fernando Salas
Eduardo Sanchez
Miguel Batista
Trever Miller (L)
Jason Motte
Ryan Franklin
Bryan Tallet (L)
Bryan Augenstein - 60-day DL as of Apr 13, 2011 (Right groin strain)
***6/7/11***Fernando Salas (1.88 ERA, 1.01 WHIP, 11 S) earns his first save in exactly one week in a 7-4 Cardinals win at the Astros. Salas worked two innings on the night for his 11th save of the season and struck out three while yielding a run. His short time in the closer role in St. Louis gives him a small sample size in terms of his numbers, but they're good numbers. Salas remains a No. 2 closer. His 44 pitches make him a candidate for a day off on Wednesday, so look for Eduardo Sanchez to get a shot at a save chance for the Cardinals.

San Diego Padres:
Heath Bell
Mike Adams
Chad Qualls
Luke Gregerson
Cory Luebke (L)
Ernesto Frieri
Pat Neshek
Joe Thatcher (L) - 60-day DL as of Mar 22, 2011 (Strained left shoulder)
***6/7/11***Heath Bell (1.73 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 17 S) is a model of efficiency in locking up his 10th straight save, a 2-0 Padres win over the Rockies. Bell throws nine of his 12 pitches for strikes and gives up a single and uncorks a wild pitch along the way, but the outcome was never in doubt. Bell remains an elite source of saves in all fantasy baseball formats.

San Francisco Giants:
Brian Wilson
Jeremy Affeldt (L)
Sergio Romo
Javier Lopez (L)
Guillermo Mota
Ramon Ramirez
Jose Casilla
Santiago Casilla - 15-day DL as of Apr 1, 2011 (Right elbow inflammation)
***6/5/11***Brian Wilson (3.00 ERA, 1.44 WHIP, 17 S) owns five straight saves after dominating the Rockies in a 2-1 Giants victory. Just when we doubted Wilson's recent run of outings he produces his best inning since May 19th. Wilson goes 1-2-3 for the first time since May 20th and strikes out a pair of Rockies along the way. We know he's a No. 1 closer, and this may be a step toward pitching that way on a consistent basis.

Seattle Mariners:
David Aardsma - 15-day DL as of Mar 22, 2011 (Recovery from labral left hip surgery)
Brandon League
Aaron Laffey (L)
Chris Ray
Jamey Wright
David Pauley
Jeff Gray
***6/5/11***Brandon League (4.68 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 16 S) works a perfect ninth for his 7th straight save in a 9-6 Mariners win over the Rays. League hasn't allowed a run since May 13th, but he isn't quite as dominant as other closers (.251 career avg. against). While the pitching-heavy Mariners are winning close games, however, League is a viable option for saves. He's converting at an 84% rate which is good enough to be trusted as a No. 2 option. He may suffer through periods of ineffectiveness going forward.

Tampa Bay Rays:
Kyle Farnsworth
Joel Peralta
Juan Cruz
J.P. Howell (L)
Adam Russell
Cesar Ramos (L)
***6/7/11***Kyle Farnsworth (1.23 ERA, 0.68 WHIP, 12 S) picks up his seventh straight save in a 4-1 Rays win at the Angels. Farnsworth struck out one over a perfect inning to collect save No. 12 on the night. More strikeouts would be welcomed as that 5.7 K/9 rate is underwhelming to say the least. Still, Farnsworth is limting hits (14 in 22 innigs) and owns just one walk in 2011. He's no better than a No. 2 closer, but he's pitching like a No. 1 for the time being. Having pitched on four of the last five days, however, look for Farnsworth to earn a well-earned day off or two.

Texas Rangers:
Neftali Feliz
Darren Oliver (L)
Arthur Rhodes (L)
Dave Bush
Mark Lowe
Tateyama Yoshinori
Michael Kirkman (L)
Darren O'Day - 60-day DL as of Apr 27, 2011 (Torn labrum, left hip)
Tobin Mason - 60-day DL as of Apr 20, 2011 (Right elbow inflammation)
***6/5/11***Neftali Feliz (1.25 ERA, 1.29 WHIP, 13 S) works his third straight save in a 2-0 Ranger win over the Indians. Feliz has been spotless over the three chances and looks to be restoring his No. 1 closer status. He should be active in all fantasy formats and should continue to pitch at a high level.

Toronto Blue Jays:
Jon Rauch
-or- Frank Francisco
-or- Octavio Dotel
-or- Jason Frasor
Shawn Camp
Casey Janssen
Mark Rzepczynski (L)
Luis Perez (L)
Jesse Carlson - 60-day DL as of Mar 29, 2011 (Strained left shoulder, biceps)
***6/7/11***Jon Rauch (3.65 ERA, 1.09 WHIP, 7 S) earns his second straight save in an 8-5 Blue Jays win over the Royals. Rauch went 1-2-3 without a strikeout, and he owns just 17 Ks in 24 2/3 innings, hardly the stuff of your higher-end closer. That's why Rauch is in his typical battle for a closer job with Frank Francisco. At this point Rauch apears to be winning the battle. He's earned both of the Blue Jays' save opportunities over the past 12 days, and he's pitched decently over his last five outings. Francisco has gone the opposite direction. Rauch should continue to see save opportunities while he's going this well.

Washington Nationals:
Drew Storen
Sean Burnett (L)
Tyler Clippard
Todd Coffey
Doug Slaten (L) - 15-day DL as of Jun 4, 2011 (Ulnar neuritis, left elbow)
Henry Rodriguez
Cole Kimball
Craig Stammen
Chad Gaudin - 15-day DL as of Apr 26, 2011 (Right shoulder inflammation)
Elvin Ramirez - 60-day DL as of Mar 30, 2011 (Right shoulder soreness)
***6/7/11***Drew Storen (2.59 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 12 S) makes quick work of the Giants for his third straight save in a 2-1 Nationals victory. Storen needed just six pitches to get through the inning, throwing four for strikes. He's mixed in some stellar outings with some real downers of late. That makes him more of a No. 2 option going forward. Storen has pitched in three straight games, so he could be in line for a night off soon.

Saturday, October 2, 2010

2010 MLB closers - final report

***2010 MLB closer report last updated 10/2/10 12:00 AM***

For 2011 MLB closers - the most thorough information on MLB bullpens - click here.

----------
Closers are listed at the top under each team name. Their competition follows. This list will be updated throughout the regular season:

Arizona Diamondbacks:
Juan Gutierrez
Aaron Heilman
Blaine Boyer
Esmerling Vazquez
Chad Qualls

Atlanta Braves:
Billy Wagner (L)
Jonny Venters (L)
Peter Moylan
Takashi Saito
Eric O'Flaherty (L)

Baltimore Orioles:
Alfredo Simon
Matt Albers
Mark Hendrickson (L)
Koji Uehara
Will Ohman (L)

Boston Red Sox:
Jonathan Papelbon
Daniel Bard
Hideki Okajima (L)
Manny Delcarmen
Ramon Ramirez

Chicago Cubs:
Carlos Marmol
Kerry Wood
Sean Marshall (L)
Andrew Cashner
James Russell (L)
Justin Berg

Chicago White Sox:
Bobby Jenks
Tony Pena
Matt Thornton (L)
J.J. Putz
Sergio Santos

Cincinnati Reds:
Francisco Cordero
Nick Masset
Logan Ondrusek
Arthur Rhodes (L)
Jordan Smith

Cleveland Indians:
Chris Perez
Rafael Perez (L)
Tony Sipp (L)
Joe Smith
Frank Herrmann

Colorado Rockies:
Huston Street
Matt Belisle
Manuel Corpas
Rafael Betancourt
Joe Beimel (L)

Detroit Tigers:
Jose Valverde
Brad Thomas (L)
Eddie Bonine
Phil Coke (L)
Ryan Perry

Florida Marlins:
Leo Nunez
Brian Sanches
Mike Dunn (L)
Clay Hensley
Jose Veras
Burke Badenhop

Houston Astros:
Brandon Lyon
Matt Lindstrom
Wilton Lopez
Jeff Fulchino
Tim Byrdak (L)

Kansas City Royals:
Joakim Soria
Robinson Tejada
Dusty Hughes (L)
Kyle Farnsworth
Blake Wood

Los Angeles Angels:
Fernando Rodney
Brian Fuentes (L)
Kevin Jepsen
Francisco Rodriguez
Scot Shields

Los Angeles Dodgers:
Jonathon Broxton
Hong Chih Kuo (L)
Ronald Belisario
Ramon Troncoso
George Sherrill (L)

Milwaukee Brewers:
John Axford
Todd Coffey
Kameron Loe
Carlos Villanueva
Trevor Hoffman

Minnesota Twins:
Jon Rauch
Matt Guerrier
Jesse Crain
Jose Mijares (L)
Brian Dunsing (L)

New York Mets:
Francisco Rodriguez
Hisanori Takahashi (L)
Pedro Feliciano (L)
Elmer Dessens
Manny Acosta

New York Yankees:
Mariano Rivera
Joba Chamberlain
David Robertson
Boone Logan (L)
Chad Gaudin

Oakland Athletics:
Andrew Bailey
Craig Breslow (L)
Brad Ziegler
Jerry Blevins (L)
Michael Wuertz

Philadelphia Phillies:
Brad Lidge
Ryan Madson
Jose Contreras
Chad Durbin
J.C. Romero (L)

Pittsburgh Pirates:
Octavio Dotel
Evan Meek
Joel Hanrahan
D.J. Carrasco
Javier Lopez (L)

St. Louis Cardinals:
Ryan Franklin
Kyle McClellan
Mitchell Boggs
Dennys Reyes (L)
Trever Miller (L)

San Diego Padres:
Heath Bell
Luke Gregerson
Edward Mujica
Mike Adams
Joe Thatcher (L)

San Francisco Giants:
Brian Wilson
Jeremy Affeldt (L)
Sergio Romo
Guillermo Mota
Santiago Casilla - 15-day DL as of Apr 1, 2011 (Right elbow inflammation)

Seattle Mariners:
David Aardsma
Brandon League
Jamey Wright
Garrett Olson (L)
Sean White

Tampa Bay Rays:
Rafael Soriano
Joaquin Benoit
Dan Wheeler
Randy Choate (L)
Lance Cormier

Texas Rangers:
Neftali Feliz
Darren Oliver (L)
Frank Francisco
Darren O'Day
Alexi Ogando

Toronto Blue Jays:
Kevin Gregg
Jason Frason
Scott Downs (L)
Casey Janssen
Shawn Camp

Washington Nationals:
Matt Capps
Drew Storen
Sean Burnett (L)
Tyler Clippard
Miguel Batista

Saturday, March 6, 2010

2010 MLB closer rankings

***Updated: 3/8/10 @ 9:41 AM CST***

***ON HIATUS THRU MARCH 22ND; PLEASE CHECK BACK ON MARCH 23RD***

Analyzing the top fantasy closer options heading into spring 2010. Each pitcher's age he'll turn during the 2010 season is listed next to his name. Stats that follow include his 2009 season vitals and three-year averages:

For 2010 MLB closer depth chart updates, click here.

1. Jonathan Broxton, LAD (26)
2009: 2.61 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 13.5 K/9, 36 SV
3-YR: 2.85 ERA, 1.09 WHIP, 11.9 K/9, 17 SV
***Broxton earned full-time closer duties for the first time in his career in 2009. He strikes more batters than any other relief ace, but sometimes that comes at the cost of a high pitch count. That also seems to be the only thing that can slow him down. Broxton pitches for a good Dodgers team that should earn him plenty of save chances.

2. Joe Nathan, MIN (35)
2009: 2.10 ERA, 0.93 WHIP, 11.7 K/9, 47 SV
3-YR: 1.77 ERA, 0.95 WHIP, 10.4 K/9, 41 SV
***Nathan pitched part of the 2009 season not feeling at top form and still produced arguably the best season of any closer in baseball. His 47 saves were second only to Brian Fuentes' 48. Nathan had bone chips removed from his elbow in October, and he was removed from his first outing this spring with elbow soreness. We're not willing to write him off until further news breaks, but Nathan may become one of the enigmas of the 2010 season; he's good enough to be the second-best closer in baseball, but his injury situation may derail his season.

3. Jonathan Papelbon, BOS (29)
2009: 1.85 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 10.1 K/9, 38 SV
3-YR: 2.02 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, 10.3 K/9, 38 SV
***Papelbon's season was a tale of two halves. He walked 18 batters and gave up four home runs before the all-star break, then bounced back with just six walks and one homer allowed the rest of the way. He tinkered with his delivery and approach last offseason, so getting used to the changes may have taken their toll early on. In the end, Papelbon remains a relief ace. His 1.84 career ERA speaks to his continuing dominance late in games.

4. Mariano Rivera, NYY (40)
2009: 1.76 ERA, 0.90 WHIP, 9.8 K/9, 44 SV
3-YR: 2.12 ERA, 0.90 WHIP, 9.6 K/9, 37 SV
***Rivera actually bettered his three-year averages at the age of 39 and posted his best ERA since 2005. He's got to slow down at some point, and he started slowly in 2009. Then he posted better numbers than anyone at the closing position. Pitching for a sure-fire winner this season keeps him near the top of the closer heap.

5. Heath Bell, SD (33)
2009: 2.71 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 10.2 K/9, 42 SV
3-YR: 2.72 ERA, 1.09 WHIP, 9.4 K/9, 14 SV
***Bell saved 42 games for a Padres team that won just 75 times. The longtime understudy to Trevor Hoffman finally stepped into the closer role and continued to post strong numbers that were a general improvement on his career marks. He had some tough times with the Yankees earlier in his career but no clunker seasons since arriving in San Diego three years ago.

6. Francisco Rodriguez, NYM (28)
2009: 3.71 ERA, 1.31 WHIP, 9.7 K/9, 35 SV
3-YR: 2.92 ERA, 1.28 WHIP, 10.6 K/9, 45 SV
***Last season, K-Rod seemed far removed from his record-setting 2008. Rodriguez actually pitched well in his new home, but it was his road troubles (5.52 ERA away from Citi Field) that turned in a mediocre statline. His 6.75 ERA after the all-star break speaks to wearing down at the end of the year and could be a result of averaging 73-plus innings over the last seven seasons. Expect improved numbers from the 28-year-old in 2010, but don't assume he'll ascend to past success.

7. Huston Street, COL (27)
2009: 3.06 ERA, 0.91 WHIP, 10.2 K/9, 35 SV
3-YR: 3.27 ERA, 1.03 WHIP, 10.0 K/9, 23 SV
***He trends hot and cold, which can be devastating for fantasy owners, but when he's good (which is more often than not), Huston Street is a legitimate No. 1 fantasy baseball closer. After losing his closer role in April, Street regained form and saved 35 games. He's on a Rockies team expected to contend in 2010, an he can dominate when in form, posting WHIP averages of 0.91 over the past three seasons.

8. Brian Wilson, SF (28)
2009: 2.73 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, 10.3 K/9, 38 SV
3-YR: 3.41 ERA, 1.26 WHIP, 9.5 K/9, 28 SV
***Wilson led full-time closers with seven blown saves last year, but that was the lone blemish on an otherwise outstanding seasons. He improved dramatically in his second full season as Giants closer, giving up ten fewer runs in ten more innings than he did in 2008.

9. Jose Valverde, DET (32)
2009: 2.33 ERA, 1.13 WHIP, 9.3 K/9, 25 SV
3-YR: 2.84 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 10.3 K/9, 39 SV
***Valverde battled injuries and a bad baseball team to put together a stat-strong season outside of his 25 total saves. Now that he's in Detroit pitching for a contender, expect Valverde to turn in his usual productive year. He posted save totals of 47 and 44 before last year's so-so mark. We'll expect him to approach 40 in 2010.

10. David Aardsma, SEA (28)
2009: 2.52 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, 10.1 K/9, 38 SV
3-YR: 4.31 ERA, 1.46 WHIP, 9.7 K/9, 13 SV
***After starting his year behind Brandon Morrow for the Seattle closer role, Aardsma eventually took over and put together easily the best season of his career. The former first-round pick finally made good on his promise, and he could've topped 40 saves with ease had he opened the year as Seattle's stopper. Because he's only put it all together this one time, we'd like to see him do it again before we consider him a sure-fire No. 1 closer. Until then, he's on the edge of the top group.

11. Joakim Soria, KC (26)
2009: 2.21 ERA, 1.13 WHIP, 11.7 WHIP, 30 SV
3-YR: 2.09 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, 10.0 WHIP, 30 SV
***Prognosticators don't particularly like Soria's fantasy outlook because he pitches for the perennially last-place Royals, but that's not our opinion. Two years ago Soria saved 42 games for Kansas City, and the only thing that stopped him from approaching 40 saves again was time spent on the disabled list. His shoulder woes of a year ago were a concern, but he bounced back nicely with 69 strikeouts in 53 innings. His dominant stuff puts him right at the edge of the No. 1 closer group, and a better team would make him an injury-risk top-six or -eight closer. Only pass him up if there's further concern about his arm this spring.

12. Francisco Cordero, CIN (35)
2009: 2.16 ERA, 1.32 WHIP, 7.8 K/9, 39 SV
3-YR: 2.83 ERA, 1.28 WHIP, 10.0 K/9, 39 SV
***Reliability is perhaps Cordero's greatest strength. Over the past three seasons, you knew exactly what you were getting. A good ERA, a mediocre WHIP, enough Ks and a solid average of 39 saves. He's not an elite closing option, but he's good enough to demand a spot as a low-end No. 1 closer. With his age creeping up, we'll look for cracks in the foundation or younger emerging stars to pass him by, but he's held them off to this point.

13. Andrew Bailey, OAK (26)
2009: 1.84 ERA, 0.876 WHIP, 9.8 K/9, 26 SV
3-YR: N/A
***Bailey began the year as the A's third option at closer and wound up winning AL rookie of the year as the team's relief ace. He saved 26 saves and produced stunning ERA and WHIP numbers that will have fantasy owners reaching a little to grab him earlier than he should be valued in year two. Bailey posted an ERA of 3.50 as mostly a starter in the minors while his strikeout rate actually improved at the MLB level. We like him as an outside shot as a No. 1 closer, but really no better than that. If he was on a contender, Bailey would have to jump up into that top tier.

14. Trevor Hoffman, MIL (42)
2009: 1.83 ERA, 0.91 WHIP, 8.0 K/9, 37 SV
3-YR: 2.81 ERA, 1.02 WHIP, 7.9 K/9, 36 SV
***No longer the power closer he once was, Hoffman's best seasons are likely behind him, especially now that 2009 is in the rear-view mirror. At age 41, Hoffman turned in an All-Star performance by closing 37 of his 41 save chances. It's hard to believe he can keep it up for much longer, but there's really no reason to doubt his ability after last season. Hoffman is no worse than a high-end No. 2 closer, but he can finish with near-elite status on a decent Brewers team.

15. Billy Wagner, ATL (38)
2009: 1.72 ERA, 1.02 WHIP, 14.9 K/9, 0 SV
3-YR: 2.40 ERA, 1.03 WHIP, 10.9 K/9, 20 SV
***Write sleeper all over Wagner in 2010. He's a dominant career relief ace who is back from injury, and last season he proved dominant in a setup role for the Red Sox down the stretch. Now with the Braves, he's not on a particularly good baseball team, so his chances may be a bit limited for saves. He's also not expected to pitch on back-to-back days, further limiting saves chances. All things considered, we'd rather bet on Wagner than bet against him. His body of work is nothing short of hall of fame, and he should be a consistently good pitcher even if he can't make it past 30 saves in 2010. We list him as 15th on our closer list, but he can slide up into the top 10 or 12 easily.

16. Brian Fuentes, LAA (35)
2009: 3.93 ERA, 1.40 WHIP, 7.5 K/9, 48 SV
3-YR: 3.22 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, 9.2 K/9, 32 SV
***Fuentes managed an anomaly of a season, posting a league-high 48 saves with one of the more mediocre closer statlines in baseball. His 7.5 K/9 and 1.40 WHIP expose his inability to dominate, but to his credit he still got the job done for the Angels. Fuentes was largely unchallenged in Anaheim last year thanks to injuries decimating the bullpen. Now he'll have to fend off the likes of Scot Shields and dare we say Fernando Rodney. He's still the man, but if he coughs up a few more saves in 2010, there will be less leeway than last year.

17. Rafael Soriano, TB (30)
2009: 2.97 ERA, 1.06 WHIP, 12.1 K/9, 27 SV
3-YR: 2.95 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 10.5 K/9, 13 SV
***Tampa tried nine different pitchers in save situations in 2009, but Soriano figures to get the lion's share this year. He has the stuff to dominate, as evidenced by his impressively low WHIP and high K/9 numbers in 2009. Soriano has battled injuries and some inconsistency in his career, but if he puts it together, he's immediately an elite saves option. Tampa manager Joe Maddon has a track record of trying to find the right matchups for his relievers, so lefty J.P. Howell may take a a couple of handfuls of opportunities away from Soriano, but he's the man moving forward.

18. Frank Francisco (31)
2009: 3.83 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, 10.4 K/9, 25 SV
3-YR: 3.82 ERA, 1.30 WHIP, 9.9 K/9, 10 SV
***One of the game's exciting arms is still a bit of a fantasy baseball enigma. Francisco can dominate, but he is prone to struggle at times. He can rattled off a string of saves last season, but he also broke down with injuries. More often than not, he is brilliant. Francisco won the Rangers closer job last season, holding off a decent candidate in C.J. Wilson, and it appears the job is safely his in 2010. Wilson still lurks (if he doesn't make the rotation), as does youngster Neftali Feliz. Francisco can be one of the game's best closers if he can put together a full season.

19. Ryan Franklin, STL (37)
2009: 1.92 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, 6.5 K/9, 38 SV
3-YR: 2.91 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, 5.7 k/9, 19 SV
***In his first full fantasy-ownership-worthy season since he was a starter back in 2003 with Seattle, Franklin put up the best season of his career for five months. Then the wheels fell off in September. Franklin does pitch for a contender in St. Louis, but he doesn't fill out the statline like your typical stopper. He's 37 on opening day, and that means he possesses almost no upside. We'll call 2009 a career year and expect his numbers to slip in 2010.

20. Carlos Marmol, CHC (27)
2009: 3.41 ERA, 1.46 WHIP, 11.3 K/9, 15 SV
3-YR: 2.54 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 11.8 K/9, 8 SV
***Marmol is a maddening talent capable of dominating like few other relievers in baseball while simultaneously shooting himself in the foot. He strikes out well over 11 batters per inning for his MLB career, but he hit 12 batters in 2009 and walked almost eight per nine innings. That's not closer material, and yet Marmol wrestled the job away from Kevin Gregg last year and enters 2010 the Cubs' clear-cut favorite to take the reigns. On the positive side, he's never been as wild as he was last season. On the negative, he's going to get himself and potentially your fantasy team in trouble.

21. Bobby Jenks, CHW (29)
2009: 3.71 ERA, 1.28 WHIP, 8.3 K/9, 29 SV
3-YR: 3.00 ERA, 1.08 WHIP, 7.2 K/9, 33 SV
***This is one of the more difficult projections heading into the 2010 season. Jenks posted the worst save total of his four-year run as White Sox stopper, but he actually improved his strikeout numbers (8.3 K/9 in 2009 vs. 5.5 K/9 in 2008). He's no fantasy ace, and while he remained a No. 2 closer for most of last season, he's no lock to remain the Sox closer this season with people like J.J. Putz and Matt Thornton breathing down his neck. Ozzie Guillen seems to like Jenks, though, and the big man dropped some weight and stopped drinking in the offseason. He's in pretty good shape going into 2010 and still one of the game's top 20 closers.

22. Chad Qualls, ARZ (31)
2009: 3.63 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 7.8 K/9, 24 SV
3-YR: 3.11 ERA, 1.19 WHIP, 8.4 K/9, 13 SV
***Possessing the makeup to close, Qualls finally got his shot in 2009. His seems had it's ups and downs, but the only thing stopping Qualls from approaching 30 saves was a dislocated kneecap with a handful of weeks to go in the season. He's on schedule to start the year as Diamondbacks closer, but Juan Gutierrez might push him a little for the job. We expect Qualls to earn the position out of spring training, but there's no reason for the contract player not to be trade bait come the July 31st deadline. Gutierrez might get his chances again late in the year.

23. Leo Nunez, FLA (26)
2009: 4.06 ERA, 1.25 WHIP, 7.9 K/9, 26 SV
3-YR: 3.70 ERA, 1.25 WHIP, 6.9 K/9, 9 SV
***Nunez inherited the Marlins closer job midway through 2009 and did a decent-enough job to hold the position the remainder of the year. He's not overpowering, but he has good stuff. He enters the year as the Marlins full-time closer with room for improvement. He's worth drafting as a third closer or potentially a low-end No. 2.

24. Brad Lidge, PHI (33)
2009: 7.21 ERA, 1.81 WHIP, 9.4 K/9, 31 SV
3-YR: 4.02 ERA, 1.40 WHIP, 11.1 K/9, 30 SV
***Lidge is as good as it gets when he's right, and he's incredibly awful when he's wrong. Last year, he was all wrong. Whether he fought injuries or simply struggled doesn't matter, a 7.21 ERA and 1.81 WHIP certainly cost the Phillies and numerous fantasy franchises. He can bounce back with elite numbers, but now at the age of 33, you have to expect Lidge's best days (which were dominant) to be well behind him. We're looking for something along the line of his three-year average in terms of a projection for this year. Anything worse and he could lose his job.

Garnering consideration:

Kerry Wood
Mike Gonzalez
Matt Capps
Jason Frasor
Octavio Dotel
Brandon Lyon
Matt Lindstrom
J.P. Howell
Jim Johnson
C.J. Wilson
Kevin Gregg
Juan Gutierrez
Ryan Madson

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

2009 MLB Closers

MLB closer report updated 2/10/10 @ 10:22 AM CST

***For 2010, please see 2010 MLB Closers***


------------
List of MLB closers and candidates at the close of the 2009 season. Closers are listed at the top under each team name:

Arizona Diamondbacks:
Chad Qualls - 60-day DL, dislocated left knee cap (August 31)
Juan Gutierrez
Esmerling Vasquez
Clay Zavada (L)

Atlanta Braves:
Rafael Soriano
Mike Gonzalez
Peter Moylan
Eric O'Flaherty (L)

Baltimore Orioles:
Jim Johnson
Danys Baez
Chris Ray
Cla Meredith

Boston Red Sox:
Jonathan Papelbon
Billy Wagner (L)
Takashi Saito
Hideki Okajima (L)

Chicago Cubs:
Carlos Marmol
Kevin Gregg
Angel Guzman
John Grabow (L)

Chicago White Sox:
Bobby Jenks
Matt Thornton (L)
Octavio Dotel
Scott Linebrink
Tony Pena

Cincinnati Reds:
Francisco Cordero
Arthur Rhodes (L)
Nick Massett

Cleveland Indians:
Kerry Wood
Chris Perez
Joe Smith

Colorado Rockies:
Huston Street
Rafael Betancourt
Franklin Morales (L)
Matt Daley
Manny Corpas - 15-day DL, right elbow surgery (might be out for season)
Alan Embree (L) - 15-day DL, fractured right tibia (out for season)

Detroit Tigers:
Fernando Rodney
Brandon Lyon
Bobby Seay (L)
Joel Zumaya - 60-day DL, right shoulder soreness (July 18)

Florida Marlins:
Leo Nunez
Matt Lindstrom
Dan Meyer (L)
Kiko Calero
Scott Proctor - 60-day DL, right elbow surgery (out for season)

Houston Astros:
Jose Valverde
LaTroy Hawkins
Doug Brocail
Jeff Fulchino

Kansas City Royals:
Joakim Soria
Juan Cruz
Kyle Farnsworth

Los Angeles Angels:
Brian Fuentes
Jason Bulger
Kevin Jepsen
Darren Oliver (L)
Scot Shields - 60-day DL, left knee surgery (out for season)

Los Angeles Dodgers:
Jonathan Broxton
George Sherrill (L)
Ramon Troncoso
Guillermo Mota
Hong-Chih Kuo (L)

Milwaukee Brewers:
Trevor Hoffman
Todd Coffey
David Weathers
Mitch Stetter (L)
Mark DiFelice

Minnesota Twins:
Joe Nathan
Matt Guerrier
Jon Rauch
Pat Neshek - 60-day DL, right elbow surgery - out for season
Jose Mijares (L)

New York Mets:
Francisco Rodriguez
J.J. Putz - 60-day DL, right elbow surgery (out for season)
Pedro Feliciano (L)
Brian Stokes
Sean Green

New York Yankees:
Mariano Rivera
Phil Hughes
Brian Bruney
Phil Coke (L)
Damaso Marte (L)

Oakland Athletics:
Andrew Bailey
Brad Ziegler
Michael Wuertz
Santiago Casilla
Joey Devine - 60-day DL, out for season (April 4)

Philadelphia Phillies:
Brad Lidge
-or- Ryan Madson
Brett Myers
J.C. Romero (L) - 15-day DL, strained left forearm (July 23)

Pittsburgh Pirates:
Matt Capps
Joel Hanrahan
Tyler Yates - 15-day DL, right elbow surgery - out for season (May 16)

St. Louis Cardinals:
Ryan Franklin
Jason Motte
Kyle McClellan
Denny Reyes (L)

San Diego Padres:
Heath Bell
Edward Mujica
Luke Gregerson

San Francisco Giants:
Brian Wilson
Sergio Romo
Jeremy Affeldt (L)
Bob Howry
Merkin Valdez

Seattle Mariners:
David Aardsma
Mark Lowe
Sean White
Miguel Batista

Tampa Bay Rays:
Troy Percival - 15-day DL, right shoulder tendinits (May 22)
J.P. Howell (L)
Randy Choate (L)
Dan Wheeler
Grant Balfour
Jason Isringhausen - 60-day DL, torn right elbow ligament (June 14)

Texas Rangers:
Frank Francisco
C.J. Wilson (L)
Eddie Guardado (L)
Neftali Feliz

Toronto Blue Jays:
Jason Frasor
Scott Downs (L)
Brandon League
Jesse Carlson

Washington Nationals:
Mike MacDougal
Sean Burnett (L)
Tyler Clippard
Ron Villone

Thursday, September 3, 2009

Closers on the cheap

Doug Miller of MLB.com writes up the pleasant surprises at closer in 2009. These are guys who weren't expected to jump into a saves role and exceeded expectations at great values. They are:

David Aardsma, SEA ($419K in 2009/33 saves)
Ryan Franklin, STL ($2.5M in 2009/36 saves)
Frank Francisco, TEX ($1.615M in 2009/22 saves)
Jonathan Broxton, LAD (1.825M in 2009/30 saves)
Heath Bell, SD ($1.255M in 2009/33 saves)
Andrew Bailey, OAK ($400K in 2009/21 saves)

Fantasy Imapct: Aardsma, Franklin and Bailey could all be had off the waiver wire in fantasy baseball this season. Broxton, Bell and Francisco were likely drafted in most leagues. Certainly, all six of these pitchers provided value over and above their salaries for big league clubs, but in fantasy play, Aardsma, Franklin and Bailey provide the kind of steals that can push a team over the top to win a league title. There will be closers like them available again next year - pitchers like Brandon Lyon in Detroit, Neftali Feliz in Texas and Billy Wagner where ever he lands. Closers can always be found on the cheap in fantasy play.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Closers on the hot seat

KFFL considers Leo Nunez and Brad Lidge to be the closers closest to losing their jobs down the stretch. Kevin Gregg received what amounts to honorable mention for his recent struggles. Agreed.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Top 2009 MLB closers - first 1/3 of season

Spitting Seeds' rankings for the best closers of the first third of the 2009 season. This is not a projection. It is an assessment of how effective baseball's top closers performed.
-----------------

Top Tier - No. 1 closers

1. Trevor Hoffman (15 saves, 0.00 ERA)
2. Heath Bell (18 saves, 1.37 ERA)
3. Francisco Rodriguez (16 saves, 0.61 ERA)
4. Frank Francisco (12 saves, 0.46 ERA)
5. Jonathan Broxton (14 saves, 1.50 ERA)
6. Jonathan Papelbon (15 saves, 2.08 ERA)
7. Joe Nathan (13 saves, 1.93 ERA)
8. Francisco Cordero (15 saves, 2.00 ERA)
9. Mariano Rivera (14 saves, 3.20 ERA)
10. Ryan Franklin (13 saves, 1.23 ERA)
11. Bobby Jenks (13 saves, 3.15 ERA)
12. Brian Fuentes (16 saves, 4.97 ERA)
-----------------

Second Tier - No. 2 closers

13. Brian Wilson (16 saves, 3.45 ERA)
14. George Sherrill (12 saves, 2.66 ERA)
15. Matt Capps (14 saves, 5.49 ERA)
16. David Aardsma (10 saves, 1.84 ERA)
17. Chad Qualls (12 saves, 3.97 ERA)
18. Huston Street (11 saves, 2.84 ERA)
19. Scott Downs (8 saves, 2.13 ERA)
20. LaTroy Hawkins (8 saves, 2.54 ERA)
21. Joakim Soria (7 saves, 1.74 ERA)
22. Mike Gonzalez (8 saves, 2.67 ERA)
23. Andrew Bailey (5 saves, 1.93 ERA)
24. Matt Lindstrom (11 saves, 5.92 ERA)
-----------------

Third Tier - No. 3 closers

25. Fernando Rodney (11 saves, 4.68 ERA)
26. Brad Lidge (13 saves, 7.27 ERA
27. Kevin Gregg (10 saves, 4.62 ERA)
28. Rafael Soriano (5 saves, 0.98 ERA)
29. C.J. Wilson (4 saves, 3.33 ERA)
30. Kerry Wood (8 saves, 5.31 ERA)
31. Brad Ziegler (5 saves, 4.07 ERA)
32. Troy Percival (6 saves, 6.35 ERA)
33. Brandon Morrow (6 saves, 6.38 ERA)
34. Joel Hanrahan (5 saves, 6.84 ERA)
35. Ryan Madson (3 saves, 2.15 ERA)
36. Chris Sampson (3 saves, 1.70 ERA)
-----------------

Fringe closers

37. Randy Choate (3 saves, 1.93 ERA)
38. Takashi Saito (2 saves, 2.70 ERA)
39. J.P. Howell (2 saves, 2.10 ERA)
40. Leo Nunez (2 saves, 3.10 ERA)
41. Todd Coffey (2 saves, 2.57 ERA)
42. Carlos Marmol (3 saves, 3.67 ERA)
43. Carlos Villanueva (2 saves, 4.18 ERA)
44. Jose Valverde (2 saves, 5.63 ERA)
45. B.J. Ryan (2 saves, 6.91 ERA)
46. Mike MacDougal (0 saves, 6.00 ERA)

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Brewers closing in on closers

The ongoing saga that is the Milwaukee Brewers bullpen continues to twist in the wind. Rumors of Trevor Hoffman blowing in from San Diego were one thing. Now, from the East, like a cold Nor'easter comes injury-ravanged Chad Cordero into the conversation.
The Brewers have been tracking his rehabilitation since the Washington Nationals nontendered Cordero last month, and have already seen him throw at least once.

The Brewers have been linked to Cordero before, once rejecting a trade offer that would have sent Cordero to Milwaukee for second baseman Rickie Weeks during the 2007 Winter Meetings. That was at the height of his run as the Nationals' closer, a four-year period from 2003-07 in which Cordero notched 127 saves. Along the way, before his 26th birthday, he became the second-youngest player in Major League history to reach the 100-save plateau (Francisco Rodriguez owns that title, recording his 100th save as a 25-year-old).
I understand the attraction, but hasn't Milwaukee learned about shaky closers from their 2008 mess at the back of the bullpen? Eric Gagne and company proved more to be stooges than musketeers or even amigos. Now Brewers candidates Hoffman (aging) and Cordero (injured) offer them little in terms of probable stability at a position that demands it. Good luck!